Trigger Point Causes and Methods of Release
The existence of Trigger Points seems to be accepted by most practitioners of therapies directed at muscle pain relief. Although there are some practitioners that say they don’t exist. They use the idea that trigger points have not yet been fully explained as some evidence of this position. Most medical research seems to be focused on how to make athlete's muscles perform at their peak, and what makes them fail, but little clinical research seems to have been conducted on the chemistry/biology of how regular people use muscles to failure. Additionally, most clinical restoration therapies are geared towards an athlete returning to competition (i.e. exercises to strengthen some muscle group), but it is difficult for most people to follow a physical therapy regimen, after all, most people aren't looking to return to competition, they just want to live without constant pain. The following theory makes a case for the existence of trigger points as well as how manual manipulation can restore proper function. The Sliding Filament theory will be used as a basis for the discussion.
If we accept the following:
According to the Sliding Filament theory, muscle
contraction consists of bundles of long chains of sarcomeres, each of which
shortens in length a small amount. Many sarcomeres getting shorter in a
controlled way leads to shortening (contraction) of the entire muscle. Each
sarcomere contains a set of actin filaments and myosin fibrils that slide across
each other and are held there by myosin heads attaching to binding sites on the
actin based on an electrochemical signal sent from a motor neuron (action
potential). The contraction begins with Calcium ions being released into the
sarcomere, binding with Troponin, causing a shift of the Tropomyosin, revealing
a binding site that the myosin head is strongly attracted to. The myosin head
binds to the site, releasing ADP and bending at the same time, the bending
causes the fibers to slide by each other (contract). The continued sliding
(contraction) or holding of a contracted position requires an ongoing chemical
cycle requiring the use of energy (ATP). ATP breaks the bond of the myosin head
to the actin and if a continued action potential is sent to the sarcomere,
Calcium ions remain available allowing the myosin head to re-attach to a binding
site on the actin filament in order to hold or continue a contraction. Therefore
energy (ATP) is required to return a muscle from the contracted state back to
normal length. ATP must also be continuously synthesized in the muscle for the
contraction to continue. Eventually ATP and other high energy phosphates are
depleted and the muscle becomes fatigued. In a fatigued muscle, with no ATP
available, the mitochondria will remove the calcium, allowing the tropomyosin to
obscure the binding sites on the actin, and the muscle returns to a flaccid
condition, and must be rested. This type of fatigue is caused by repetitive summed muscle
stimulation called tetanic stimulation.
What causes trigger points:
Trigger Points occurring in slow twitching, type I, muscles
are caused by over-use of the muscle. The body attempts to do all it can to
maintain the contraction of a muscle that may, as far as the body knows, be
preventing certain death by allowing the person (or other animal) to maybe pull
and hold themselves in a tree to get away from an attacker. After the danger is
gone the muscle is damaged (or has triggerpoint(s)) but will repair itself if
given a chance to rest. Hopefully the creature we are talking about doesn’t have
to perform life saving over-use of muscles on a daily basis. In modern times,
muscle over-use may not be because of a life threatening situation, but the
muscles will still perform as if it were if they are told to do so. The over-use
command may come from the need to hold one’s arm up on the steering wheel of a
car, or maybe the use of a computer keyboard and mouse - the reason the Pressure
Pointer was created.
Considering the Sliding Filament model, perhaps muscles have a mechanism to hold a contraction without the requirement of ATP? I theorize that in certain types of muscle fibers, myosin heads can be relatively permanently bonded to actin filaments, instead of the ATP hungry myosin binding/releasing cycle that must occur for muscles to remain easily and quickly controlled. This state of actomyosin cross links could be caused by the calcium ion pump, the mitchondria, (or some other mechanism) to be instructed to not pump calcium out of the sarcomere in the absence of ATP. If calcium is made available without ATP, uncontrolled muscle contraction occurs and I think this is what happens to large numbers of fibers or sarcomeres in a particular muscle fiber. The body wide condition of a saturation of calcium in the sarcomere and the absence of ATP is what occurs in death, it’s called rigor mortis. Localized, uncontrolled, relatively permanent, non-energy using contractions are trigger points. Trigger points are created in muscles that must remain contracted for very long periods of time without rest. Some of these muscles are commonly used to support the neck and shoulder joints.
What releases Trigger Points:
Although the pain of trigger points can often be reduced by
the use of pain killing drugs, trigger points can be returned to normally
functioning muscle fiber by manual manipulation, or sometimes just a lot of rest
and some stretching. The degree to which a muscle is 'cramped' (the number of
dysfunctional sarcomeres) is directly related to how strongly the muscle will
try to remain that way, so trigger points that were caused by carrying luggage
on a trip may be relatively easy to release if treated quickly, but if not
treated, the trigger points may grow to include adjacent sarcomeres, or cause
referred pain to other areas that are affected by the dysfunctional muscle
fibers and may result in years of pain.
In general, there are three things that can be used in combination to
return the sarcomeres to proper function, or, release trigger points; water, stretching and pressure.
Under-hydration is one of the things that can cause chemical processes in the
body to be less efficient. Proper hydration will help reduce the development of
trigger points and make them easier to treat.
Mechanically removing the stuck myosin heads from there binding sites
(stretching) is the main means for the body to begin the process of returning
the sarcomeres to proper function, applying pressure at the same time can
greatly increase the effectiveness of the stretch by mechanically inducing the
removal of calcium, hydrolyzing ATP and
replenishing other phosphates to the muscle cells. Trigger points that have existed for extended
periods, sometimes years, can be difficult to return to normal function and may
require months of stretching and pressure treatment to fully restore function,
and more importantly for most people, stop the pain.
Gary Turell – March 2006
References:
http://www.emc.maricopa.edu/faculty/farabee/BIOBK/BioBookMUSSKEL.html
http://www.emc.maricopa.edu/faculty/farabee/BIOBK/BioBookTOC.html
http://fig.cox.miami.edu/~cmallery/150/neuro/muscle.htm
http://web.indstate.edu/thcme/mwking/muscle.html
http://labs.ansci.uiuc.edu/meatscience/Library/contraction%20and%20relaxation.htm